Event details from: ASMF Seminar: Sliem el Ela (UvA)

Date
22 March 2024
Time
12:30 – 13:30

Abstract

The new pension contracts under the Future Pensions Act (Wtp) include a solidarity reserve that can be used for risk sharing between age groups within a pension fund. This paper answers the question of whether the solidarity reserve leads to a structural redistribution element (PAYG) from young to old within a pension fund, and if so, what its magnitude is. In doing so, we examine the implementation of the solidarity reserve as the vast majority of pension funds intend to use it. This implementation aims to avoid nominal reductions in commenced pensions. Within this objective, different variants are conceivable for the exact specification of the filling and distribution rules of the solidarity reserve. This paper analyses eight different variants. For some other variants, our conclusion is that there may not be a significant redistribution element from young to old. However, there are also some variants where we conclude that there is a redistribution element from young to old. For the variants calculated in our paper, the magnitude of the implicit debt is about 1 to 25 billion. This is the implicit debt expressed at the national level, in other words: the implicit debt if all Dutch pension funds were to opt for this variant. By comparison, the implicit debt of the older system amounts to about 50 billion.

The insights from this paper are relevant for pension fund managers when making decisions on the design of the filling and distribution rules of the solidarity reserve. The presence or absence of a structural redistribution element, and its magnitude, is important information for executive decision-making. Over the past fifteen years, there has been considerable policy attention to the abolition of the average system, which contains an implicit debt of about 50 billion as a result of a redistribution element from younger to older workers. A reason for the introduction of the Wtp was to lead to the abolition of this redistribution element. The question now on the table for pension fund managers is whether it is desirable to introduce a new redistribution element through the solidarity reserve.

Speaker

Sliem el Ela (University of Amsterdam)